How It Works

never ending cookie jar cookie of the month subscription cookies and cream
never ending cookie jar baker sprinkles icing sugar from a sieve on holiday cookies

What we Offer

Each month you will receive a different, handcrafted cookie. Each cookie is designed and made in our own kitchen.  The flavor changes each month, and we choose the flavor.  We offer cookies by the dozen and they can be pick-up/delivered locally or shipped. Each month there is an alternate cookie flavor for those who do not want the current flavor, or who have an ingredient allergy. 

How It Works

On the 20th of each month we announce the following month’s Cookie of the Month flavor.  You will receive an email which explains what the cookie will be and what flavors it will contain. Our kitchen usually begins baking orders on the first of every month.  We aim to get as many orders as possible baked and delivered within the first week of the month.  If you love your cookies, you can always order more thru the 19th of the month. If your cookies require shipping, we expertly package and ship using USPS or UPS 2-3 day priority.  We carefully monitor all cookies to make sure they are received in a timely manner. If you need to delay your cookies, or have any other issue, we are always available by email.  We value your business and support and will be 100% flexible and try to accommodate what requests we can.

The Never Ending Cookie Jar Promise

Our promise is simple but sincerely heartfelt!

We promise to give you exciting and new flavors each month. Each recipe is family tried, tested and tasted until we feel it’s the best it can be! We promise to add a little happiness to your day when your cookies arrive. We promise that if for some reason you are not satisfied, to try to make it right. Just reach out to us and let us know. We promise to try to resolve any issue quickly and with excellent service.


Most frequent questions and answers. Click a question to expand.

Our cookies are 100% handmade. We bake in small batches to ensure that each cookies is loaded with top quality ingredients. Although we don’t use entirely organic ingredients we do use a LOT of them. Our cost also includes the cost for shipping. Each recipe is also 100% created from scratch. Just taste our cookies and you’ll agree it’s a small price to pay.

Major credit cards through Stripe (no Stripe account required)

Yes, the prices listed include the cost for shipping.

We ship each batch via UPS or USPS priority mail. These packages are generally delivered within 2-3 days. We provide tracking details and carefully monitor all shipments to make sure your cookies arrive in top notch shape.

No, at this time we only ship within the United States.

We package each cookie of the month to ensure freshness. Because each cookie varies, packaging varies month to month. We do test package each cookie to make sure your cookies arrive fresh.

Absolutely! Our head baker is always looking to know your thoughts and ideas. Just email us at co*****@ne******************.com While we can’t guarantee we can make your idea come to life, we would love to hear what you think.

No, our kitchen is not nut free. Our cookies are also not peanut allergy friendly. We do list each ingredient in our cookies and would be happy to share those with you prior to purchase should you have allergy concerns.

We are a small, family-run business.  We are fortunate enough to have our very own “cookie house” which is an entire single-family home dedicated solely to baking cookies.  Our cookie kitchen looks exactly like your kitchen at home.  We use the same type of ovens, mixers, measuring cups and spoons that any at-home baker would.  We just happen to bake only cookies in our kitchen.  We are known as a “cottage food bakery.”

No, once your order has been placed, we are unable to make any changes.
However, you may reach out and lets us see at what process your order is at. We’ll work to accommodate if we can.

At this time we do not offer gift cards.

Absolutely! We love giving gifts, and who doesn’t love receiving homemade cookies? Just let us know who your gift is for and what type of gift message you would like to go into your cookies.

While we do only offer one Cookie of the Month flavor, we understand that you may not wish to enjoy that cookie. Each month there is an alternate flavor for you to choose instead. The alternate flavor does not change each month. Currently we offer The Triple Chocolate  in the winter months and The Lemon in the summer months.

While we hope that you enjoy every single bite, we understand sometimes this might not be the case. Please reach out to us if you are dissatisfied for any reason, and we can work together to find a resolution.

We do not offer gluten free or vegan cookie options at this time.

If you have an issue with your order, please contact us immediately so we can assist. co*****@ne******************.com

The Never Ending Cookie Jar is currently a mail order business. But who knows, maybe someday!

Our cookie kitchen is located in Mebane, NC.  If you select local pick up at check out, you will receive an automatic discount of 33% off.  This discount is given ONLY for customers who choose to physically pick-up their cookie orders from our local Cookie House.  We do deliver directly to your door anywhere in the USA for the prices listed on our website.